Authors
Prof T. Nataraja Moorthy
Abstract
Fire plays a vital role in the survival of not only early humans but also modern humans. Humans have used fire in rituals, cooking, generating heat and light, signalling, propulsion purposes, forging, cremation, and as a weapon or mode of destruction. Fire investigation is very challenging for the investigator to conclude because the physical evidence turned to ashes in the fire. Any forensic investigator's primary aim is to discover the origin and cause. The cause of the fire may be accidental, arson, natural calamities and even unknown causes. Arson is the intentional setting of fire on one's own or others' property. Understanding the psychological aspects of fire setting is essential to controlling and deterring arson. Psychology is the branch of science that deals with mental processes and behaviour. The forensic investigator must assess the involvement of any physiological behaviour to trigger the fire unconsciously to find out the origin and cause. It assists in focusing the path of investigation, identifying potential suspects, and developing appropriate techniques and strategies for interviewing the various types of firesetters. The author, also a former forensic crime scene investigator in India, presents a case study on the psychological aspects of fire investigation and the challenges faced in identifying the origin and cause of the fire. Keywords: Forensic psychology, Fire scene investigation, Case study, India.
Introduction
Fire plays a vital role in the survival of not only early humans but also modern humans. Humans have used fire in rituals, cooking, generating heat and light, signalling, propulsion purposes, forging, cremation, and as a weapon or mode of destruction (John, 2016). The destruction of physical evidence, so important for identification and crime reconstruction, remains a frustrating problem (Nataraja, 2008). The primary aim of any forensic fire investigator is to find out the origin and cause of the fire. The cause of the fire may be accidental, arson, natural calamities and even unknown causes. Arson is an intentional set fire on one's or others' property. The investigator should observe and mentally note the scene condition, any visible victims, the damage caused by the fire, and any witnesses or bystanders. The initial observation stage can contribute to the investigation, no matter how small the details, which will lead the investigators on the right path and help them decide if the fire was caused intentionally (David, 2019).
The three key elements to be considered for arson include: i) there has been a burning of property, ii) the burning is incendiary in origin and iii) the burning was started with the intent of destroying the property (Lentini, 2012). The National Centre for Analysis for Violent Crime, USA, have classified the motives for arson as i) vandalism, ii) excitement, iii) revenge, iv) profit, v) crime concealment, and vi) extremism and to prove the commission of arson crime, the cause of the fire has to be determined (Quintiere, 2006). From a psychological perspective, a fire setting is viewed as a function of a disturbed personality.
Therefore, arson may be viewed as a mental health problem and not a criminal act. One of the most frequent emotions acted out by expressive arsonists is anger. Psychologists have stated that one of the reasons many offenders commit arson is because these pathological individuals redirect their anger onto buildings of owners and even parents or relatives, as they see them as easier targets and a way to channel all of their aggression (Jackson et al., 1987).
References
Dara, Mojtahedi., et al. "Making an Arsonist: A Psychological Approach to Understanding Expressive Arson". EC Psychology and Psychiatry, vol. 4, no..3, 2017, pp. 94-99.
David, De Tata. "Forensic Sciences/Arson residue". Encyclopaedia of Analytical Science, 2019, pp.8-16.
DeHaan and John. "Kirk's Fire Investigation". 7th edition, New Jersey, 2012, pp.800.
Jackson., et al. "Why are arsonists not violent offenders?". International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology. vol. 31,1987, pp.143-151.
James, Quintiere. "Fundamentals of Fire Phenomena". John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Chichester, 2006, pp.450.
John, Gowlett. "The discovery of fire by humans: a long and convoluted process". Philosophical Transactions. Royal Society B. vol. 371, 2016, pp.1-12.
Lentini, John. "Scientific Protocols for Fire Investigation". 2nd edition, CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, 2012, pp.646.
Nataraja Moorthy, Tharmar, et al. "A challenging crime scene investigation report: Alleged murder, unravelled the mystery as lightning death". Journal of Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences University. vol.10, no. 4: 2021, pp.111-115.
Nataraja Moorthy, Tharmar. "Challenging fire investigation". Tamilnadu Police Journal. Vol..2, no. 1, 2008, pp.66-85.
Nataraja Moorthy, Tharmar. "Crime Concealment Act and Crime Scene Confusion. Forensic Way of Solvation - Crime Scene Investigation Reports". IASR. International eConference- Forensic Science, 2022, Conference Proceedings, pp.47-56.
Nataraja Moorthy, Tharmar. "Crime reconstruction: A tool to solve the mystery and achieve justice – An interesting crime scene report". The Egyptian Journal of Forensic Sciences and Applied Toxicology. vol. 20, no.4: 2020, pp.85-89.
Nataraja Moorthy, Tharmar. "Footprint evidence solved the mystery in a suspicious death: A rare case report". Peer-reviewed Journal of Forensic & Genetic Sciences. vol.3, no. 2, 2019, pp.183-185.
Tim, Newburn. Criminology. (3rd edn), Taylor & Francis Ltd, 2017, pp. 1144.
How to cite this article?
APA Style | Moorthy, Prof. T. N. (2024). Mysterious Serial Fires in a Private Hospital – A Rare Arduous Forensic Investigation Report. Academic Journal of Forensic Sciences, 07(01), 45–48. |
Chicago Style | |
MLA Style | |
DOI | |
URL |